Files
Fr0zkaandClaude Opus 5.5 753cc9c259 tools(verify): fast/medium/full verification tiers with a compiled-in source stamp (L39); research R6
BuildLinux.sh hashes a sorted manifest of compiled inputs into VOXELFORGE_SOURCE_STAMP, printed first by
every executable; Standalone/Tools/verify/verify.py checks it before and after each tier and records
binary/input hashes and the resolved recipe, style map and layout. Fast (163 s) runs on the canonical owner
world only and asserts FI Style 2 / SW Style 1; medium (8 min) and full (26 min) add the style matrix,
GCC, determinism and cost. Controls: stale source, mislabelled style-0 owner, all-black capture, L30/L31,
L35/L36 and the L38 step are all rejected. No geometry change; owner hashes identical to L37.
Research R6: leak table, generator contract and a 10-step metre-native migration plan.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_016dhxM43dnWvUu2B5Ph1iG1
2026-10-23 15:27:52 +02:00

3.5 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Shared notes (researcher R6 <-> implementer L39), newest at bottom

R5 read-only architecture findings (2026-10-23)

Inspected Standalone/BuildLinux.sh, Build.ps1, Core/core_sources.txt, Source/StreamBenchmarkHeadless.cpp, Source/LinuxOffscreenCapture.cpp, data/owner_world.json, the L37 passage/invariant/legacy/ring/capture/crease/fragment runners, Saved/Linux/l37/mouth-curves-run/layout-owner-fi.json, and the R5/L37 reports. No source was changed and no binary was run.

  • BuildLinux.sh reads Core/core_sources.txt, generates wrapper translation units under Standalone/Build, compiles the Core and compatibility objects, then links VoxelForgeCoreHeadless-$VARIANT. It separately compiles LinuxOffscreenCapture.cpp into VoxelForgeOffscreenCapture-$VARIANT. The generated wrappers/objects are build outputs; the stamp manifest should hash the listed original source paths, core_sources.txt, both standalone executable sources, and the build scripts. No stamp exists today. The script already enforces taskset -c 0-11 plus prlimit --as=6442450944 and rejects --jobs above 12.
  • There are two executable entry points to stamp. StreamBenchmarkHeadless.cpp parses options before its first current log ([HeadlessConfig]); LinuxOffscreenCapture.cpp checks argc before logging. Print the source stamp at the start of both mains, before parse/validation. A cheap stamp-only option on each binary would let the shared runner reject stale binaries before expensive work.
  • The canonical JSON contains FI PassageConfig.Style=2 and SW PassageConfig.Style=1. The checked-in L37 capture and passage runners label linux25-owner-*-style0.json as owner-*; those are style overrides. In an existing resolved snapshot, each strates[] entry has generator_kind, recipe_id, and IDs, while passages[] has geometry, but neither exposes the effective style. The requested style assertion cannot be made from the current snapshot: add the resolved passage style per strate to its serialization, then assert FI=2/SW=1. stable_identity is the existing layout ID (resolved-layout-v3-fnv64:…); the recipe audit log reports recipe but not style.
  • The L37 runners each create their own subprocess wrappers and summaries. A shared helper can centralize the constrained invocation, stamp-only preflight, expected-stamp recomputation, binary/input SHA-256, resolved-layout extraction, and a common summary row (stamp, binary hash, input hash, actual recipe/style/layout ID, elapsed time). Recompute the manifest after the tier. Resolve the canonical layout once per owner case and use that same snapshot for all gates/captures.
  • CapturePassageStandardSetL37.py and CaptureMouthOverviewL37.py only check JPEG size. An all-black JPEG therefore passes. Add decoded-pixel variance/coverage validation (without PIL, which the earlier research could not import) and include a black-image negative control.
  • RunMouthCreaseAuditL37.py imports the fragment audit. For each candidate it reads the mesh once in BASE.audit, then visible_crease reads it again for the near view and again for overview. A combined analyzer can decode once, then share triangles/buckets for fragment, crease, and both views. Existing overview check matters: L37 passed near at 4.40° but measured 25.54° against 20° at overview.
  • RunRingAuditsL37.py already keeps the L30 terrace and L31 flat meshes as live controls; the full LOD0–8 work is separate from targeted LOD0 checks. The R5 split can reuse AuditRingTerraceL32.py directly for fast LOD0 plus those controls.